Hitler’s Jewish problem

Courtesy of MCT

A recent article in Britain’s Daily Telegraph has published the results of DNA tests of Adolf Hitler’s nearly 40 living relatives in Europe and America revealing that the virulently anti-Semitic Nazi leader was of Jewish ancestry.

The article itself draws no conclusions from this result, except to generically suggest the possibility of a case of Jewish “self-loathing,” and to point out the parallel between another recently outed outspoken opponent of Israel, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, evidence of whose own Jewish ancestry recently surfaced.

The DNA result bolsters the circumstantial findings of many researchers who had long traced Hitler’s ancestry to the house of a Jewish financier in the city of Graz named Frankenburger. They had also noted Hitler’s own awareness of the fact, which he repeatedly avoided and suppressed throughout his career.

Now that historians need not quibble over Hitler’s identity, which has been confirmed, they are to immediately consider the more important allegation and determine in what way were Hitler’s policies, so outwardly antagonistic to Jews, also Jewish, without resorting to the deus ex machina of self-loathing or defaming those interested in finding the truth as anti-Semites.

The paradox of an anti-Semitic Jew stands at the gate of the truth: why would a Jew persecute other Jews?

By way of a brief answer, the research of those like Leni Brenner, a Jewish historian, whose works include “Zionism in the Age of Dictators,” record in minute detail high level contacts and cooperation between Nazi party officials and Zionists.

On this taboo ground we begin to perceive that Nazi policies and Zionist policies were far from incompatible, they were complementary.

It took decades for word of a secret alliance between Nazism and Zionism to surface, whose chief fruit was the top secret “Transfer Agreement” of 1933 or as it was called in Hebrew, the “Ha’avara Agreement” struck between Zionists and Nazis, by which the Nazi government segregated and then shipped “desirable” Jews to Palestine to build that country in accordance with the Zionist design.
In this light, perhaps the views of Christian Zionist pastors like John Hagee, who are the darlings of Israel and whose every word is sponsored by Zionists the world over, are not as outlandish as they seem.

Hagee recently preached that Hitler was a hunter sent by God to chase the unwilling Jews, the majority of whom were anti-Zionists who regarded Zionism as “a fanciful and unrealistic movement,” out of their comfortable homes in Europe into the deserts of Palestine. According to Brenner, “the majority of the Jews of Poland, in particular, had repudiated Zionism on the eve of the Holocaust (and) abhorred the politics of (Zionist) Menachem begin (up until) September 1939.”

It was for this reason that the famous Jewish writer George Steiner wrote in one of his works without undue sentimentality that without Hitler, the 2000 year old dream of Zionism would never have been realized, and that he, this now confirmed Jew, was the true founder of Israel.

When the descendants of the Zionists, the hard-line Jews of Israel and the hawkish Jewish neo-conservatives of America and Europe compare Ahmadinejad to Hitler, most rational people did not take them seriously, thinking it was another ruse to launch another ”war of choice.” But are they not a thousand times justified?

A secret Jew at the head of a foreign government making a grand show as the foremost Jew-hater on earth, whose policies will ultimately benefit and not harm Zionist interests.

Matthew Soldad contributed to this report

top

Disclaimer: The Daily Sundial is not responsible for comments posted on dailysundial.com. In accordance with the Communications Decency Act of 1996 the Sundial is not liable for the content of comments. By commenting, all persons posting on dailysundial.com have agreed to our comment policy. If a comment does not abide by the comment policy the Sundial reserves the right to delete comments without warning. The Daily Sundial advises persons commenting not to abuse their First Amendment rights, and to avoid comments of hate speech or encouraging violence.

  • Opinionated

    Seriously guys! The Fox is quite correct. Why waste your time on these pathetic little issues? Hitler is dead. The nazi holocaust is over. But fascism still exists today and so does the totalitarianism of capitalism and the State. There are far worse forms of oppression than just “campus anti-semitism”. I get more disgusted over editorials praising nationalism or the capitalist system than ones suggesting Hitler had Jewish roots. Yes, I HATE FASCISM but Hitler is dead and the USA and Israel are still committing horrid atrocities around the world. What’s more important to be angry about here and now?

  • The Fox

    @Alice Anonymous

    Where you’ve seen me talking negative about the Jewish people? The problem you ignorant prick is not the people but the Israeli state. Truth-Seeker does not mention Zionism as it was during the 40′s and 50′s. He is talking abt neo-zionism. Can you understand the difference between these two? Calling him nazi is the biggest crap I could ever seen!!! Really nonsense.

    Hugo Chavez has no problem with Jewish people. It is the Israeli policies that he criticizes because Israel is controlled by the USA government and the capitalists. Nothing to do with Jewish people. Believe me if you were in Europe in 1940 you would wish to have somebody like Chavez with you to save you from Hitler’s wrath. It was Hitler who persecuted both the Jewish and the communists cause he though that they would go to take over the world. So calling Chavez anti-Semitic is just pure nonsense propaganda.

    Ahmadinejad… where you have seen me supporting any leader like that? So, why did you mention his name? I am atheist but I do respect any religion and yes I agree that Jewish in Germany may have no voice just like any other minority (immigrants, Muslims, Eastern European, Gypsies). Please stop pretending that you know everything cause what you are getting silly and completely ignorant. Stop watching TV all the time and see the truth. Do you understand that all this division (Jewish, muslim, Christian) are nothing more but tactics of the ruling class to push the “divide and rule” agenda? Unless you are so blind and you want to spend your whole life patronizing the elites by supporting this division. Try to understand the difference between the state and the people firstly and then we talk again.

  • Alice Anonymous

    @Truth-Seeker: Hello Neo-Nazi! First of all, Zionism is an extremely arbitrary concept. There are many definitions for it and not everybody who believes in it believes it to be the enslaving concept as you see it. That is a very anti-semitic point of view. Second of all, to even imply that Hitler helped the Jews in any way is a disgusting misuse of the brain.

    @The Fox: Hello Mr. patronizing, ‘I am better than you’ prick! I have no idea what you are speaking about. Jonathan was not saying that he believes in the conspiracies that that book spews out. Furthermore, unless you want to see another holocaust happening and if you ever want all the genocides to stop, people need to speak up against these outrageous conspiracy theories! Go to Venezuela and see what Hugo Chavez is saying about Jews. And as the author of the articles says, go to Iran and see how much tolerance Ahmadinejad has for them, too.

    And that is just speaking about Jews. Atrocious persecutions and genocides are happening on all over the world!!! Somebody needs to speak up for these people who have no voice!!! The Jews had no voice for ten years in Germany! Now it is everybody’s turn to speak up for all the others who do not have a voice!!

    I do admit that you are right about capitalism…a lot of these people do not have a voice because of it. If Exxon/Mobil would keep out of Africa we may actually be able to at least help some people there!

  • The Fox

    @Jonathan Mann
    Can you please prove me what does this “Conspiracy straight out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion” means? How silly is that you all believe in unprovable secret conspiracies… Seriously get a life and start worrying about things that actually exist. Stop wasting your life being pawns of capitalism and serving the well known “divide and rule” strategy of the elites.

  • The Fox

    I find the whole DNA concept really stupid. I can’t believe that in 2010, in a society where the minimum education is available for almost everyone people still come up to such stupid conclusions and still continue thinking about DNA which is nothing more but a separatist propaganda.

    Seriously stop watching TV. Get a life and book some tickets, travel, see the world outside of your little pingeon hole read some books. The world is not only what the TV tells you

  • Truth-Seeker

    Great article!

    For Rachel, Alice, and Jonathan: realize international relations isn’t black-and-white. Nationalists and state leaders will act in their own interest REGARDLESS of the ethics involved because their roles require it. Yes, zionism is like any other form of nationalism. It is enslaving, not liberating. For the nationalist, the State is an extension of the ego. That’s why nationalists (like the zionists who collaborated with nazis) will try to defend their nationalist-statist intentions and will always try to present their nationalism as some kind of moral philosophy.

    In short: don’t worship the State kiddies. Free yourself from the mental slavery of nationalism and start thinking about all of humanity.

    (A)

  • Jonathan Mann

    Rachel & Alice said it well.

    Conspiracy straight out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

  • Alice Anonymous

    The Daily Sundial forgot to tag this as ‘blatant racism.’

    “A secret Jew at the head of a foreign government making a grand show as the foremost Jew-hater on earth, whose policies will ultimately benefit and not harm Zionist interests.”

    Just to get this straight, this article is saying that starting with the Nuremberg Laws in 1935 and ending with the liberation of the Jews from the concentration camps in 1945 was Hitler’s way of benefitting his “own people?” Killing 6 million of this “own people” and torturing the rest, in unspeakable ways, benefitted the Jews to such a great extent that we would think that people might actually learn something from one of, if not the most, deplorable events that occurred in this century.

    “I remember one set of twins in particular: Guido and Ina, aged about four. One day, Mengele took them away. When they returned, they were in a terrible state: they had been sewn together, back to back, like Siamese twins. Their wounds were infected and oozing pus. They screamed day and night. Then their parents – I remember the mother’s name was Stella – managed to get some morphine and they killed the children in order to end their suffering.”

    -Vera Alexander

  • Alice Anonymous

    The Daily Sundial forgot to tag this as ‘blatant racism.’

    “A secret Jew at the head of a foreign government making a grand show as the foremost Jew-hater on earth, whose policies will ultimately benefit and not harm Zionist interests.”

    Just to get this straight, this article is saying that starting with the Nuremberg Laws in 1935 and ending with the liberation of the Jews from the concentration camps in 1945 was Hitler’s way of benefitting his “own people?” Killing 6 million of his “own people” and torturing the rest, in unspeakable ways, benefitted the Jews to such a great extent that we would think that people might actually learn something from one of, if not the most, deplorable events that occurred in this century.

    “I remember one set of twins in particular: Guido and Ina, aged about four. One day, Mengele took them away. When they returned, they were in a terrible state: they had been sewn together, back to back, like Siamese twins. Their wounds were infected and oozing pus. They screamed day and night. Then their parents – I remember the mother’s name was Stella – managed to get some morphine and they killed the children in order to end their suffering.”

    -Vera Alexander

  • Rachel Tabachnick

    There is a serious problem with this article. For one thing the study did not conclude that Hitler was of Jewish ancestry but only that he carried the H1B1B1 gene, not uncommon in Southern Europe and found in about 9% of Austrians. Unfortunately the UK Telegraph story on which other outlets (including several Jewish publications) based their story was very sloppily researched.

    The claim that Hitler’s father Alois was fathered by the son of a Jewish employer of Hitler’s mother is a myth that has been solidly debunked by historians. Ian Kershaw, author of an extensive biography of Hitler, points out that these rumors started in the 1920s and 30s and became more widespread after claims made by Nazi lawyer Hans Frank prior to his execution at Nuremberg. But there was no family by that name in Graz where Alois Hitler was born in 1837. Jews had been expelled from that particular region in the 1500s and were not allowed to settle there until the 1860s.

    The narrative of Hitler’s Jewish ancestry is widely used in “New World Order” conspiracy narratives in which it is claimed that the world is controlled by a satanic bloodline of Jews/Illuminati. Some right wing evangelists such as John Hagee, founder of Christians United for Israel, also widely broadcast this conspiracy narrative that Hitler was partially Jewish and part of a line of satanic “half-breed Jews.” Read more about this at http://www.talk2action.org/story/2010/8/24/18554/3489 and
    http://www.talk2action.org/story/2010/8/24/19257/3498

    Note that I have worked for years doing research on the dangers of Christian Zionism. I am a vocal supporter of a two state resolution of the Israel/Palestinian conflict and as frustrated as anyone with the obstructionism of the current Israeli government and their partnership with extremists, both Jewish and Christian. However, repeating conspiracy theories will not help bring peace to the Middle East.