Lilly Ledbetter shares her story of overcoming the wage gap
“It is important in our country that we are paid equitably and fairly,” she said. “It is a family affair to be paid properly. It’s the difference between paying tuition, your mortgage or putting food on your table.”
Although Ledbetter’s battle led to President Barack Obama signing the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act of 2009, it took her 19 years working as a manager at Goodyear to learn about the drastic difference in pay between her and her male coworkers, and it was only through an anonymous note.
“I was making 40 percent less than those men,” she said. “After realizing that, I finally got enough energy to do my 12 hour shift, then thought about how my overtime, my retirement, 401K and social security were all based on what I was earning.”
Based on Ledbetter’s research, and the help and support of her family, she decided to file a lawsuit with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
After several months the EEOC told her she had one of the strongest cases they had ever seen.
“I had no savings to support a large law bill so the lawyer took the case on a contingency basis, they would get 50 percent of whatever I won,” she said.
The court ruled in her favor, awarding her $3.8 million, but a stipulation in the Civil Rights Act of 1991 stated that a “limitation on the amount of damages (caps) is based on the size (number of employees) of the respondent.” In Ledbetter’s case, she could only receive $300,000, half of which would go to her attorney and then be taxed.
The blows continued as Ledbetter lost the case in an appeal, and after taking it all the way to the Supreme Court in 2006, she lost again due to another stipulation in the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which states employees could only file a pay discrimination lawsuit 180 days after their first paycheck.
“But most people wouldn’t think to go to EEOC in their first six months, you’re trying a new job, to learn the ropes and make a good impression, not file a lawsuit,” she said.
Additionally, Ledbetter had no way of knowing how much her coworkers were making and Goodyear discouraged employees from asking.
Choosing not to give up, she lobbied for another three years and The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act was passed, altering the previous stipulation to allow employees to file pay discrimination lawsuits 180 days after their last paycheck.
“I lost the battle, but won the war,” Ledbetter said. “Never did I dream my name would be on a Supreme Court case or that the justices would have a say with Lilly from Alabama or that my name would be on a law.”
Ledbetter added that the pay gap between men and women has not changed in 10 years and women are only making 77 cents per dollar to men, a difference that can’t be fixed with a college degree. Recent graduates make 82 cents to every dollar.
“Equal pay was passed 50 years ago, but the problem is no one has been enforcing it. I’ll drive 80 mph if I don’t see any officers around,” she said. “People aren’t paying the legal wage and in younger grades they’re suffering in education and with obesity, their moms can’t afford to work less or cook food.”
The next step, Ledbetter said, is passing Tom Harkin’s (D-IA) Paycheck Fairness Act, which would loosen some restrictions of the Equal Pay Act of 1963 regarding filing lawsuits and make it easier for people to find out how much their coworkers earn.
Second would be to2 get rid of the cap the Civil Rights Act of 1991 placed on the amount people can receive in damages.
Dean of the College of Humanities, Elizabeth Say, added that women’s studies has a very strong presence on this campus and has since 1970.
“The health and quality of the department is thanks to many women who have fought and committed themselves to gender and women’s studies,” she said. “I don’t think it’s any coincidence that CSUN is the only CSU with three strong female presidents.”